Why we’re all in on performance branding. – and how it can transform your growth.

Why Your Best Customers Aren’t Clicking Your Ads: The Performance Branding Secret

Dereka Smith

February 18, 2025

We’ve been sold a lie about attribution modeling that benefits ad platforms, not advertisers.” -Bryan Karas

Competitive costs in the digital marketing world are at a breaking point. With Meta’s ad costs up 30% and every brand fighting over the same pool of ready-to-buy customers, something’s got to give. 

In a recent episode on the Catching Fire podcast, our CEO, Bryan Karas, sheds light on a better way forward: performance branding. This isn’t just another marketing buzzword – it’s a practical solution backed by real results. 

Take OhmConnect, who saw their customer base jump 20% by shifting focus to educational content, or NCSA (Next College Student Athlete), who drove an impressive 30-40% more conversions by reallocating their bottom-funnel spending. 

As privacy changes shake up the digital world, these results prove what we’ve suspected all along: great marketing isn’t about chasing quick clicks – it’s about building genuine connections that convert.

What we’ve learned from this episode:

  • Most brands are overspending on bottom-funnel ads, creating expensive bidding wars.
  • Your best customers probably won’t click on your first ad – they’re doing their homework first.
  • Moving just 20% of your budget to brand awareness can transform your results.
  • Quick-click customers often bring less lifetime value than those who convert later.
  • You need to get your direct response foundation solid before scaling up.
  • Smart upper-funnel spending beats throwing more money at saturated channels.

 

Listen for more insights into the future of performance marketing:

Spotify -> https://bit.ly/4iLQn4L

YouTube -> https://youtu.be/cR7MF1pGeMQ

Ready to transform your marketing strategy? Contact us to learn how performance branding could reshape your brand’s growth trajectory.

Dereka Smith

Dereka Smith is a sales and marketing specialist at Playbook Media, where she shares the latest insights and strategies to fellow marketers. With 3 years experience in the B2B sector, she specializes in email marketing and copywriting that drives real results—whether it’s boosting lead conversions or building brand loyalty. Outside of Playbook Media, Dereka works as a freelance email marketer for early-stage startups, blending data-driven insights with creative storytelling to help founders stand out in crowded markets.

Subscribe to the blog

Designing for Attention: Creative Principles Every Digital Advertiser Should Know

Dereka Smith

April 23, 2025

Why Cutting Creative Corners Tanks Your Paid Media ROI

Andrea Cheung

April 16, 2025

Effective Ad Creative Testing Strategies: How to Run A/B Tests in 2025

Erica Peacock

April 10, 2025

Let's Talk

In 30 minutes, we’ll help you find millions of wasted marketing dollars.